The reason we have this problem is that so much of the West is owned by "us," or "the U.S.," or something. You may not have known that, but it matters a lot for context. Check out this map:
Click for an even more federally-owned image.
Now, there is a genuine kerfuffle about land rights. Not ownership, exactly, but the right to use the land for cattle grazing. Adverse possession, Lockean combining my labor (or cattle) with the land, and so on. There's this. And then this.
These people are crazy, right? Why don't they graze their cattle on private land, and stop whining? Check out Nevada, folks. In the map above. There is no private land.
Have we reached a cow tipping point? What is going to happen? My answer: sell it, sell most of it. My friend Holly Fretwell at PERC wrote about this back in 2003. Fifteen years ago, Terry, Vernon, and Emily worked on this. It's not like we didn't know. Sell it. SELL IT! More recently, Holly is still trying to get someone to listen.
Click for an even more federally-owned image.
Now, there is a genuine kerfuffle about land rights. Not ownership, exactly, but the right to use the land for cattle grazing. Adverse possession, Lockean combining my labor (or cattle) with the land, and so on. There's this. And then this.
These people are crazy, right? Why don't they graze their cattle on private land, and stop whining? Check out Nevada, folks. In the map above. There is no private land.
Have we reached a cow tipping point? What is going to happen? My answer: sell it, sell most of it. My friend Holly Fretwell at PERC wrote about this back in 2003. Fifteen years ago, Terry, Vernon, and Emily worked on this. It's not like we didn't know. Sell it. SELL IT! More recently, Holly is still trying to get someone to listen.